AI novel critique
RevisionGrade evaluates novels as manuscripts, not prompts. The critique is designed around evidence-backed diagnosis, story criteria, revision priorities, and author-controlled next steps.
RevisionGrade is The Literary AI Partner: manuscript diagnosis, author-controlled revision, and professional submission preparation for serious writers.
What this page covers
A useful novel critique should identify what is working, what is not working, what evidence supports the finding, and what revision priority follows from it.
RevisionGrade separates diagnosis from repair so a manuscript is not flattened by premature line editing or generic AI rewriting.
The page is prepared for public-domain sample evaluations and founder evaluation case studies. The proof asset is the evaluation report, not the full manuscript.
Proof assets
These pages are designed to show evaluation outputs without publishing full manuscripts. When PDFs are uploaded, each HTML page should summarize the diagnosis and link to the quality-gated PDF report.
Sample report page
A public-domain sample page prepared for a full RevisionGrade evaluation report once the quality gate is ready.
Open page →
Sample report page
A public-domain Gothic sample page for showing how RevisionGrade diagnoses concept, atmosphere, pacing, voice, and reader trust.
Open page →
Sample report page
A public-domain fantasy sample page for showing how a criteria-based evaluation handles wonder, world logic, stakes, and closure.
Open page →
Founder case study
Evaluation-report-only founder case study for an upmarket suspense manuscript. The manuscript itself is not published on the page.
Open page →
Founder case study
Evaluation-report-only founder case study for an upmarket eco-thriller manuscript. No full manuscript text is published.
Open page →
Founder case study
Evaluation-report-only founder case study for a mythic eco-fantasy manuscript. The page is designed for diagnosis proof, not manuscript disclosure.
Open page →
FAQ
No. The sample and founder pages are designed to publish evaluation reports only, with score summaries and diagnostic findings. Full manuscripts, full chapters, and extended copyrighted text should not be published on these pages.
Public-domain novels let RevisionGrade show evaluation behavior on recognizable works without exposing private manuscripts or modern copyrighted books.
Founder case studies show how the same evaluation framework handles real long-form manuscripts by the founder while keeping the manuscript text private.
They should contain the evaluation report: mode, score snapshot, confidence, evidence-backed findings, revision priorities, and limitations. They should not contain the full manuscript.
Start with diagnosis
RevisionGrade turns manuscript evidence into diagnosis, revision priorities, and submission preparation without surrendering author control.